Following India’s 2-2 series draw against England, former New Zealand all-rounder Craig McMillan pointed out a key gap in the Indian Test squad — the absence of a genuine fast-bowling all-rounder.
He noted that a player with Hardik Pandya’s skill set could have been invaluable, especially in conditions outside Asia. Pandya’s ability to bowl effective medium pace while also contributing crucial runs in the lower order, McMillan argued, brings balance and depth to a side.
Without such an option, India’s team composition in overseas Tests tends to rely heavily on specialist bowlers and pure batters, limiting tactical flexibility. McMillan’s comments served as a reminder that India’s success abroad often depends on the presence of players who can bridge the gap between batting and bowling.
Conditions and Role Adaptability
McMillan further explained that while fast-bowling all-rounders are essential on pitches that favour seam and swing, conditions in Asia require a different approach. In subcontinental matches, spin-bowling all-rounders such as Ravindra Jadeja, Washington Sundar, and Ravichandran Ashwin become more effective due to turning tracks and slower surfaces.
Their ability to contribute both with bat and ball in familiar conditions makes them ideal for home Tests. However, McMillan maintained that having the option of a seam-bowling all-rounder remains crucial for tours to England, Australia, South Africa, and New Zealand. Without this versatility, India risks being predictable in its playing XI selections, potentially making it harder to adapt mid-series to changing pitch and weather conditions.
Shubman Gill’s First Test Series as Captain
Apart from highlighting India’s balance concerns, McMillan praised Shubman Gill’s performance in his first Test series as captain. Leading against a challenging opponent like England was no small task, and McMillan acknowledged that Gill likely made mistakes, as any new leader would under pressure.
He emphasised that such experiences are part of a captain’s growth, and Gill has shown encouraging signs of leadership potential. With guidance from head coach Gautam Gambhir, McMillan suggested that Gill should work on developing his own distinct style of captaincy — one that reflects both his personality and tactical instincts.
As Gill gains more exposure in different playing conditions, McMillan believes his decision-making will become sharper, and his ability to manage high-pressure moments will improve. The combination of leadership growth and better squad balance, McMillan implied, could make India an even stronger Test side in the future.
Get the latest cricket news here, like us on Facebook, and follow us on Twitter and Instagram for more such updates.